| Adrian College | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Adrian | MI | III | |
| Albion College | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Albion | MI | III | |
| Albright College | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Reading | PA | III | |
| Alfred State College | Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Alfred | NY | III | |
| Alfred University | Empire 8 | Alfred | NY | III | |
| Allegheny College | North Coast Athletic Conference | Meadville | PA | III | |
| Alma College | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Alma | MI | III | |
| Alvernia University | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Reading | PA | III | |
| Amherst College | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Amherst | MA | III | |
| Anderson University (Indiana) | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Anderson | IN | III | |
| Anna Maria College | Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Paxton | MA | III | |
| Augsburg University | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Minneapolis | MN | III | |
| Augustana College (Illinois) | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Rock Island | IL | III | |
| Aurora University | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | Aurora | IL | III | |
| Austin College | Southern Athletic Association | Sherman | TX | III | |
| Averett University | USA South Athletic Conference | Danville | VA | III | |
| Baldwin Wallace University | Ohio Athletic Conference | Berea | OH | III | |
| Bates College | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Lewiston | ME | III | |
| Becker College | Commonwealth Coast Football | Worcester | MA | III | |
| Belhaven University | American Southwest Conference | Jackson | MS | III | |
| Beloit College | Midwest Conference | Beloit | WI | III | |
| Benedictine University (Illinois) | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | Lisle | IL | III | |
| Berry College | Southern Athletic Association | Mount Berry | GA | III | |
| Bethany College (West Virginia) | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Bethany | WV | III | |
| Bethel University (Minnesota) | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | St. Paul | MN | III | |
| Birmingham-Southern College | Southern Athletic Association | Birmingham | AL | III | |
| Bluffton University | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Bluffton | OH | III | |
| Bowdoin College | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Brunswick | ME | III | |
| Bridgewater College (Virginia) | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Bridgewater | VA | III | |
| Bridgewater State University | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Bridgewater | MA | III | |
| Buena Vista University | Iowa Intercol. Athletic Conf. | Storm Lake | IA | III | |
| Buffalo State, State University of New York | Empire 8 | Buffalo | NY | III | |
| California Lutheran University | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | Thousand Oaks | CA | III | |
| Capital University | Ohio Athletic Conference | Columbus | OH | III | |
| Carleton College | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Northfield | MN | III | |
| Carnegie Mellon University | University Athletic Association | Pittsburgh | PA | III | |
| Carroll University (Wisconsin) | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Waukesha | WI | III | |
| Carthage College | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Kenosha | WI | III | |
| Case Western Reserve University | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Cleveland | OH | III | |
| Castleton University | Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Castleton | VT | III | |
| Catholic University | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | Washington | DC | III | |
| Central College (Iowa) | Iowa Intercol. Athletic Conf. | Pella | IA | III | |
| Centre College | Southern Athletic Association | Danville | KY | III | |
| Chapman University | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | Orange | CA | III | |
| Christopher Newport University | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Newport News | VA | III | |
| Claremont McKenna-Harvey Mudd-Scripps Colleges | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | Claremont | CA | III | |
| Coe College | American Rivers Conference | Cedar Rapids | IA | III | |
| Colby College | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Waterville | ME | III | |
| College at Brockport, State University of New York | Empire 8 | Brockport | NY | III | |
| Concordia College, Moorhead | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Moorhead | MN | III | |
| Concordia University Chicago | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | River Forest | IL | III | |
| Concordia University Wisconsin | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | Mequon | WI | III | |
| Cornell College | Midwest Conference | Mt. Vernon | IA | III | |
| Crown College (Minnesota) | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | St. Bonifacius | MN | III | |
| Curry College | Commonwealth Coast Football | Milton | MA | III | |
| Dean College | Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Franklin | MA | III | |
| Defiance College | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Defiance | OH | III | N/A |
| Delaware Valley University | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Doylestown | PA | III | |
| Denison University | North Coast Athletic Conference | Granville | OH | III | |
| DePauw University | North Coast Athletic Conference | Greencastle | IN | III | |
| Dickinson College | Centennial Conference | Carlisle | PA | III | |
| Earlham College | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Richmond | IN | III | |
| East Texas Baptist University | American Southwest Conference | Marshall | TX | III | |
| Elmhurst College | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Elmhurst | IL | III | |
| Emory and Henry College | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Emory | VA | III | |
| Endicott College | Commonwealth Coast Football | Beverly | MA | III | |
| Eureka College | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Eureka | IL | III | |
| Fairleigh Dickinson University, Florham | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Madison | NJ | III | |
| Ferrum College | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Ferrum | VA | III | |
| Finlandia University | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Hancock | MI | III | |
| Fitchburg State University | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Fitchburg | MA | III | |
| Framingham State University | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Framingham | MA | III | |
| Franklin & Marshall College | Centennial Conference | Lancaster | PA | III | |
| Franklin College | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Franklin | IN | III | |
| Frostburg State University | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Frostburg | MD | III | |
| Gallaudet University | Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Washington | DC | III | |
| Geneva College | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Beaver Falls | PA | III | |
| George Fox University | Northwest Conference | Newberg | OR | III | |
| Gettysburg College | Centennial Conference | Gettysburg | PA | III | |
| Greensboro College | USA South Athletic Conference | Greensboro | NC | III | |
| Greenville University | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Greenville | IL | III | |
| Grinnell College | Midwest Conference | Grinnell | IA | III | |
| Grove City College | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Grove City | PA | III | |
| Guilford College | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Greensboro | NC | III | N/A |
| Gustavus Adolphus College | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | St. Peter | MN | III | |
| Hamilton College | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Clinton | NY | III | |
| Hamline University | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Saint Paul | MN | III | |
| Hampden-Sydney College | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Hampden Sydney | VA | III | |
| Hanover College | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Hanover | IN | III | |
| Hardin-Simmons University | American Southwest Conference | Abilene | TX | III | |
| Hartwick College | Empire 8 | Oneonta | NY | III | |
| Heidelberg University | Ohio Athletic Conference | Tiffin | OH | III | |
| Hendrix College | Southern Athletic Association | Conway | AR | III | |
| Hiram College | North Coast Athletic Conference | Hiram | OH | III | |
| Hobart and William Smith Colleges | Liberty League | Geneva | NY | III | |
| Hope College | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Holland | MI | III | |
| Howard Payne University | American Southwest Conference | Brownwood | TX | III | |
| Huntingdon College | USA South Athletic Conference | Montgomery | AL | III | |
| Husson University | Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Bangor | ME | III | |
| Illinois College | Midwest Conference | Jacksonville | IL | III | |
| Illinois Wesleyan University | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Bloomington | IL | III | |
| Iowa Wesleyan University | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Mount Pleasant | IA | III | |
| Ithaca College | Liberty League | Ithaca | NY | III | |
| John Carroll University | Ohio Athletic Conference | University Heights | OH | III | |
| Johns Hopkins University | Centennial Conference | Baltimore | MD | III | |
| Juniata College | Centennial Conference | Huntingdon | PA | III | |
| Kalamazoo College | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Kalamazoo | MI | III | |
| Kean University | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Union | NJ | III | |
| Kenyon College | North Coast Athletic Conference | Gambier | OH | III | |
| King's College (Pennsylvania) | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Wilkes-Barre | PA | III | |
| Knox College | Midwest Conference | Galesburg | IL | III | |
| LaGrange College | USA South Athletic Conference | LaGrange | GA | III | |
| Lake Forest College | Midwest Conference | Lake Forest | IL | III | |
| Lakeland University | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | Plymouth | WI | III | |
| Lawrence University | Midwest Conference | Appleton | WI | III | |
| Lebanon Valley College | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Annville | PA | III | |
| Lewis & Clark College | Northwest Conference | Portland | OR | III | |
| Linfield College | Northwest Conference | McMinnville | OR | III | |
| Loras College | American Rivers Conference | Dubuque | IA | III | |
| Louisiana College | American Southwest Conference | Pineville | LA | III | |
| Luther College | American Rivers Conference | Decorah | IA | III | |
| Lycoming College | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Williamsport | PA | III | |
| Macalester College | Midwest Conference | Saint Paul | MN | III | |
| MacMurray College | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Jacksonville | IL | III | |
| Maine Maritime Academy | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | Castine | ME | III | |
| Manchester University | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | North Manchester | IN | III | |
| Marietta College | Ohio Athletic Conference | Marietta | OH | III | |
| Martin Luther College | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Ulm | MN | III | N/A |
| Maryville College (Tennessee) | USA South Athletic Conference | Maryville | TN | III | |
| Massachusetts Institute of Technology | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | Cambridge | MA | III | |
| Massachusetts Maritime Academy | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Bourne | MA | III | |
| McDaniel College | Centennial Conference | Westminster | MD | III | |
| Methodist University | USA South Athletic Conference | Fayetteville | NC | III | |
| Middlebury College | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Middlebury | VT | III | |
| Millikin University | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Decatur | IL | III | |
| Millsaps College | Southern Athletic Association | Jackson | MS | III | |
| Misericordia University | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Dallas | PA | III | |
| Monmouth College (Illinois) | Midwest Conference | Monmouth | IL | III | |
| Montclair State University | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Montclair | NJ | III | |
| Moravian College | Centennial Conference | Bethlehem | PA | III | |
| Morrisville State College | Empire 8 | Morrisville | NY | III | |
| Mount St. Joseph University | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Cincinnati | OH | III | |
| Muhlenberg College | Centennial Conference | Allentown | PA | III | |
| Muskingum University | Ohio Athletic Conference | New Concord | OH | III | |
| Nebraska Wesleyan University | American Rivers Conference | Lincoln | NE | III | |
| Nichols College | Commonwealth Coast Football | Dudley | MA | III | |
| North Carolina Wesleyan College | USA South Athletic Conference | Rocky Mount | NC | III | |
| North Central College | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Naperville | IL | III | |
| North Park University | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Chicago | IL | III | |
| Norwich University | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | Northfield | VT | III | |
| Oberlin College | North Coast Athletic Conference | Oberlin | OH | III | |
| Occidental College | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | Los Angeles | CA | III | |
| Ohio Northern University | Ohio Athletic Conference | Ada | OH | III | |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | North Coast Athletic Conference | Delaware | OH | III | |
| Olivet College | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Olivet | MI | III | |
| Otterbein University | Ohio Athletic Conference | Westerville | OH | III | |
| Pacific Lutheran University | Northwest Conference | Tacoma | WA | III | |
| Pacific University (Oregon) | Northwest Conference | Forest Grove | OR | III | |
| Plymouth State University | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Plymouth | NH | III | |
| Pomona-Pitzer Colleges | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | Claremont | CA | III | |
| Randolph-Macon College | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Ashland | VA | III | |
| Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | Liberty League | Troy | NY | III | |
| Rhodes College | Southern Athletic Association | Memphis | TN | III | |
| Ripon College | Midwest Conference | Ripon | WI | III | |
| Rockford University | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | Rockford | IL | III | |
| Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Terre Haute | IN | III | |
| Rowan University | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Glassboro | NJ | III | |
| Saint John's University (Minnesota) | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | St. Joseph | MN | III | |
| Saint Vincent College | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Latrobe | PA | III | |
| Salisbury University | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Salisbury | MD | III | |
| Salve Regina University | Commonwealth Coast Football | Newport | RI | III | |
| Shenandoah University | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Winchester | VA | III | |
| Simpson College | American Rivers Conference | Indianola | IA | III | |
| Southern Virginia University | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Buena Vista | VA | III | |
| Southwestern University (Texas) | American Southwest Conference | Georgetown | TX | III | |
| Springfield College | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | Springfield | MA | III | |
| St. John Fisher College | Empire 8 | Rochester | NY | III | |
| St. Lawrence University | Liberty League | Canton | NY | III | |
| St. Norbert College | Midwest Conference | De Pere | WI | III | |
| St. Olaf College | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Northfield | MN | III | |
| State University of New York at Cortland | Empire 8 | Cortland | NY | III | |
| State University of New York Maritime College | Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Bronx | NY | III | |
| Stevenson University | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Pikesville | MD | III | |
| Sul Ross State University | American Southwest Conference | Alpine | TX | III | |
| Susquehanna University | Centennial Conference | Selinsgrove | PA | III | N/A |
| Texas Lutheran University | American Southwest Conference | Seguin | TX | III | |
| The College of New Jersey | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Ewing Township | NJ | III | |
| The College of St. Scholastica | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Duluth | MN | III | |
| The College of Wooster | North Coast Athletic Conference | Wooster | OH | III | |
| Thiel College | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Greenville | PA | III | |
| Thomas More College | | Crestview Hills | KY | III | |
| Trine University | Michigan Intercol. Ath. Assn. | Angola | IN | III | |
| Trinity College (Connecticut) | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Hartford | CT | III | |
| Trinity University (Texas) | Southern Athletic Association | San Antonio | TX | III | |
| Tufts University | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Middlesex County | MA | III | |
| U.S. Coast Guard Academy | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | New London | CT | III | N/A |
| U.S. Merchant Marine Academy | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | Nassau County | NY | III | |
| Union College (New York) | Liberty League | Schenectady | NY | III | |
| University of Chicago | Midwest Conference | Chicago | IL | III | |
| University of Dubuque | American Rivers Conference | Dubuque | IA | III | N/A |
| University of La Verne | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | La Verne | CA | III | |
| University of Mary Hardin-Baylor | American Southwest Conference | Belton | TX | III | |
| University of Massachusetts, Dartmouth | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Dartmouth | MA | III | |
| University of Minnesota, Morris | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Morris | MN | III | |
| University of Mount Union | Ohio Athletic Conference | Alliance | OH | III | |
| University of New England | Commonwealth Coast Football | Biddeford | ME | III | |
| University of Northwestern-St. Paul | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Saint Paul | MN | III | |
| University of Puget Sound | Northwest Conference | Tacoma | WA | III | |
| University of Redlands | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | Redlands | CA | III | |
| University of Rochester | Liberty League | Monroe County | NY | III | |
| University of St. Thomas (Minnesota) | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Saint Paul | MN | III | |
| University of the South | Southern Athletic Association | Sewanee | TN | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Eau Claire | WI | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-La Crosse | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | La Crosse | WI | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Oshkosh | WI | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-Platteville | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Platteville | WI | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-River Falls | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | River Falls | WI | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Stevens Point | WI | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-Stout | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Menomonie | WI | III | |
| University of Wisconsin-Whitewater | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Whitewater | WI | III | |
| Ursinus College | Centennial Conference | Collegeville | PA | III | |
| Utica College | Empire 8 | Utica | NY | III | |
| Wabash College | North Coast Athletic Conference | Crawfordsville | IN | III | |
| Wartburg College | American Rivers Conference | Waverly | IA | III | |
| Washington and Jefferson College | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Washington | PA | III | |
| Washington and Lee University | Old Dominion Athletic Conf. | Lexington City | VA | III | |
| Washington University in St. Louis | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | St. Louis | MO | III | |
| Waynesburg University | Presidents' Athletic Conference | Waynesburg | PA | III | |
| Wesley College | Atlantic East Conference | Dover | DE | III | |
| Wesleyan University (Connecticut) | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Middletown | CT | III | |
| Western Connecticut State University | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Danbury | CT | III | |
| Western New England University | Commonwealth Coast Football | Springfield | MA | III | |
| Westfield State University | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Westfield | MA | III | |
| Westminster College (Missouri) | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Fulton | MO | III | |
| Westminster College (Pennsylvania) | Presidents' Athletic Conference | New Wilmington | PA | III | |
| Wheaton College (Illinois) | College Conference of Illinois & Wisconsin | Wheaton | IL | III | |
| Whittier College | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conf. | Whittier | CA | III | |
| Whitworth University | Northwest Conference | Spokane | WA | III | |
| Widener University | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Chester | PA | III | |
| Wilkes University | Middle Atlantic Conferences | Wilkes-Barre | PA | III | |
| Willamette University | Northwest Conference | Salem | OR | III | N/A |
| William Paterson University of New Jersey | New Jersey Athletic Conference | Wayne | NJ | III | |
| Williams College | New England Small College Athletic Conference | Williamstown | MA | III | |
| Wilmington College (Ohio) | Ohio Athletic Conference | Wilmington | OH | III | |
| Wisconsin Lutheran College | Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | Milwaukee | WI | III | |
| Wittenberg University | North Coast Athletic Conference | Springfield | OH | III | |
| Worcester Polytechnic Institute | New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference | Worcester | MA | III | |
| Worcester State University | Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Worcester | MA | III | |
